When the market is flooded with options, buying a new compact crossover SUV can be a dizzying task. With multiple powertrains, trims, and even performance versions, the options are seemingly endless. To simplify this conundrum, let’s focus on two promising contenders in the compact SUV sector: the 2023 Hyundai TUCSON and the 2023 Kia Sportage. We’ll explain the strengths, weaknesses, and distinctive traits of these popular SUVs to help you decide which is the better buy.
The Tale of Specs
At first glance, the 2023 Kia Sportage and Hyundai TUCSON seem to be pretty different. The Sportage, with its trail-ready appeal, contrasts with the more urbane TUCSON. However, you’d be surprised to discover their similar underpinnings. Both vehicles share the same platform, drivetrain, power, and even dimensions. Powered by the standard Hyundai/Kia 2.5-liter I-4 engine, both SUVs generate a solid 187 hp and 178 lb-ft of torque. This power is transferred to the wheels via the identical eight-speed automatic transmissions, which can be paired with all-wheel-drive systems.
One significant mechanical distinction is the 17-inch wheels and all-terrain tires of the Kia Sportage X-Pro. These might enhance riding comfort on the road, possibly impacting braking distance, handling, and noise marginally. However, these SUVs are probably not the go-to choices for off-road enthusiasts, as they offer similar, modest off-road capabilities.
Performance by Numbers
If speed thrills you, then you might need to look elsewhere. Each vehicle takes around 9.3 seconds to sprint from zero to 60 mph, putting them on par with your typical family hauler, not a sports car. But if it’s about one-upping the competition, the Sportage slightly outperforms the TUCSON in the quarter-mile run. Thanks to its tire edge, the TUCSON makes up for its speed with superior braking and handling prowess, edging past the Sportage in both metrics.
Analyzing Fuel Efficiency
In the realm of fuel efficiency, it’s crucial to acknowledge that neither the 2023 Kia Sportage nor the Hyundai TUCSON leads the compact SUV class. For the all-wheel-drive models, the Sportage offers 23/28/25 mpg for city/highway/combined driving, and the TUCSON offers the same. As a comparison, competitors such as the Honda CR-V and Nissan Rogue boast more impressive figures with 27/32/29 mpg and 28/35/31 mpg, respectively.
However, it’s not all doom and gloom in terms of fuel consumption for these two contenders. Both Kia and Hyundai offer hybrid and plug-in hybrid versions of these SUVs, significantly increasing their appeal to eco-conscious drivers. The Hyundai TUCSON Hybrid Limited has an impressive fuel economy of 37/36/37 mpg for city/highway/combined driving. It also boasts up to 226 hp, a considerable improvement over the base model’s 187 hp. The TUCSON plug-in hybrid ups the game even more with 261 hp and a notable ability to travel 33 miles solely on electric power.
Similarly, the Kia Sportage is competitive with its green attributes. The Sportage Hybrid SX Prestige achieves 42/44 mpg and delivers 227 hp. The Sportage X-Line plug-in hybrid also offers 261 hp, mirroring the TUCSON plug-in hybrid, but provides a slight edge with its ability to cover 34 miles on electricity alone.
Behind the Wheel
The TUCSON feels more like a sedan, offering a slightly lower driving position and a heavier steering feel than the Sportage. However, it trades comfort for firmness, transmitting road irregularities right to the driver’s seat. The Sportage feels more like an SUV, with more relaxed steering and better ride quality thanks to its off-road tires. Both vehicles sport the same 2.5-liter engines and struggle when trying to overtake others on highways or uphill, particularly when fully loaded.
However, the Sportage’s transmission tuning is a touch better, with quicker shifts and a tendency to hold lower gears for longer, making it easier to drive smoothly than the TUCSON.
Interior Showdown
Despite identical space offerings, TUCSON and Sportage take different design approaches. The TUCSON’s cabin is modern and minimalistic, with metallic accents and twin 10.3-inch screens. The Sportage, on the other hand, welcomes you with warm interior colors, wood and metal accents, and two large 12.3-inch curved displays. Functionality isn’t compromised either, with larger wireless charging slots and convertible cup holders.
However, both vehicles have their shortcomings. The TUCSON’s touch-sensitive controls are a bit finicky, and the push-button transmission takes up more space than necessary. The Sportage’s dual-function digital heating, air conditioning, and media display can be distracting and hard to operate without haptic feedback.
Value Proposition
Pricing structures reveal that the Sportage’s superior interior and smoother driving manners still allow it to come in with a starting MSRP of $26,290 compared to a slightly higher $26,900 for the TUCSON. However, the price difference is negligible when comparing the road-focused Sportage SX Prestige all-wheel drive with the TUCSON Limited. The hybrid and plug-in hybrid versions of both vehicles are worth considering. Offering improved performance and significantly better fuel economy, these versions are undeniably the better buys.
Want To Test-Drive a New or Used Kia?
Experience the thrill of driving a Kia at Tom Kadlec Kia on Highway 52 in Rochester, Minnesota. Whether you’re interested in the family-friendly spaciousness of a 2023 Kia Sportage, the urban sleekness of a 2023 Kia Sorento, or the reliable performance of a pre-owned Kia model, we’ve got you covered. Visiting our dealership provides more than just an opportunity to check out our collection. You get to experience the impressive features and ride quality of our Kia vehicles through a test drive. This unique experience will provide insights into the vehicle’s handling, comfort, performance, and technology features.
You can visit our dealership anytime during our working hours to schedule your test drive. Alternatively, you can book an appointment online through our contact form.
Conclusion
When it comes to compact SUVs, the 2023 Kia Sportage and Hyundai TUCSON both have their unique strengths. While they share many similarities, including their powertrains and basic dimensions, their individual characteristics are where they truly differentiate themselves. The Kia Sportage impresses with its robust design, stylish interior, and smart transmission tuning, making it a preferred choice for those seeking a modern, road-focused driving experience. Meanwhile, the Hyundai TUCSON shines with its car-like handling, advanced braking system, and minimalist interior design, appealing to those who favor a simpler, more streamlined aesthetic.
a black car parked in front of some trees by Hyundai Motor Group is licensed with Unsplash License
Connect with us
Recent Blog Entries
Categories
Warranties include 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain and 5-year/60,000-mile basic. All warranties and roadside assistance are limited. See retailer for warranty details.